Civil litigation refers to private litigation between individuals, businesses and government entities that does not involve criminal charges. It includes disputes over contracts, intellectual property, finance documents, insolvency, debt recovery and director or shareholder agreements. Brander Smith McKnight represents clients in these matters in and outside of court.

Sydney Lawyers Civil Litigation Experts

Civil Litigation in Australia is an umbrella term which refers to all private litigation between individuals, businesses and government entities including companies, trusts, sole traders and partnership that does not involve criminal charges. This often involves business disputes. Brander Smith McKnight’s team of civil and commercial litigation lawyers are experts in this area of law.

Commercial litigation is a term frequently used in the USA and usually refers to civil litigation involving business entities and commercial law.

The term litigation refers to the legal resolution of disputes in court. However, in reality many of these disputes are resolved without going to court using alternative dispute resolution and also tactics such as interlocutory applications. The civil litigation lawyers at Brander Smith McKnight Sydney Lawyers have extensive experience resolving disputes both in and outside of court. We pride ourselves on settling 90% of our civil litigation disputes prior to a formal hearing saving you legal expenses and time. However, if the matter proceeds to a hearing, our experienced lawyers have over 40 combined years of commercial litigation experience and will fiercely advocate for you in court.

Our experienced team provides premium and professional legal services in a cost effective manner. We understand the commercial realities of each case and provide tailored advice and strategies for success.

2 business lawyers with legal books

Recent Litigation Successes by Brander Smith McKnight Lawyers

chevronShareholder Dispute (2025)

Our client was a director and 50% shareholder of a company established by himself and a friend. Their company provided housing for NDIS clients. A dispute occurred following the purchase of a house by the company. In breach of their agreement, the other party failed to provide any funding to renovate and prepare the house. Despite extensive negotiations by the experienced lawyers at Brander Smith McKnight, the matter could not be resolved. Our civil litigation lawyers commenced proceedings in the Supreme Court to have the company wound up by court order. The case needed to be heard in the Supreme Court as it involved a corporations matter. On making the court application, the other party became willing to negotiate and subsequently the matter settled with a financial payment to our client who was able to buy the other party out.

chevronDispute over Ownership of Medical Practice (2025)

Our client was the estate of a deceased medical doctor which owned half of a company with another family member who operated a medical practice. The surviving company owner refused to compensate the estate for the estate’s share of the business and physically divided the medical practice by erecting a wall down the middle of the office. After extensive attempts to negotiate a settlement, the litigation lawyers at Brander Smith McKnight commenced proceedings for both trespass and an application in the Supreme Court to have the company wound up. At this point, the other party became willing to settle and paid our client a fair price for the company and business.

chevronCar Hire Scam following MVA (2025)

Our client was involved in a MVA and was fully insured. Their insurer paid for the repair of their car and the other vehicle involved in the MVA. About 6 months after the accident our client received a letter of demand in the amount of  $18,000 for car hire fees for the owner of the other vehicle whilst their car was being repaired. The expert litigation lawyers at Brander Smith McKnight took the matter to a hearing in the Small Claims Division of the Local Court. During the proceedings an expert witness provided a report detailing the reasonable time required for car hire during the repair. The claim was dismissed by the magistrate on the basis that the other party had insufficient evidence to support their claim.

chevron$250,000 in Compensation Payment for Breach of Confidence (2024)

Our client’s former sexual partner had posted personal information, including graphic photographs of our client on the internet. The litigation lawyers at Brander Smith McKnight sued for breach of an implied agreement with the reasonable assumption that our client’s former partner would keep the information confidential. After extensive negotiation during litigation, the matter was settled, the offending material was removed and our client received $250,000 in compensation payment for the breach of confidence.

Commercial Disputes

Commercial disputes concern businesses, including sole traders, a company or partnership. Business disputes may arise for any number of reasons and can affect businesses of all sizes. They may relate to:

  1. Contracts
  2. Intellectual Property
  3. Finance Documents such as Loan Agreements and Guarantees
  4. Insolvency
  5. Debt recovery
  6. Directors or Shareholders Disputes
  7. Building and Construction Disputes
  8. Employment Disputes

Non Commercial Disputes

Non commercial disputes is a term that is most frequently used in the USA and refers to disputes between individuals rather than business entities.

Civil Litigation

The umbrella term of civil litigation encompasses disputes between both individuals and business entities. It includes the previously mentioned disputes involving contracts, employment, shareholder, intellectual property, partnership, directors, building and construction, financial documents, insolvency, intellectual property and debt recovery.  In addition it includes:

  1. Defamation Actions
  2. Legislative Proceedings, for instance, disputes between neighbours, involving the Trees (Disputes between Neighbours) Act 2006 NSW.
  3. Torts, which are private legal actions not involving a contract.  Examples of this include The Tort of Trespass, The Tort of Nuisance and The Tort of Negligence.

Alternative Dispute Resolution

Alternative dispute resolution refers to the methods used to resolve legal disputes outside of court. Resolving commercial disputes outside of court can save parties to a dispute both time and money and can avoid the stress associated with litigation. Our expert civil litigation lawyers at Brander Smith McKnight law firm Sydney can explain the alternative dispute resolution options available and advise on their relative suitability to your case. Some common methods are described below.

Negotiation

This is an informal method of alternative dispute resolution that sees the parties discussing the problem at hand and attempting to reach a solution through compromise. This can be attempted before or after seeking legal advice. It is a simple and often efficient method to resolve disputes. The civil and commercial litigation lawyers at BSM are expert negotiators and are able to put forward your issues in a concise and winning manner. A high percentage of our client’s disputes are favourably resolved using this technique.

Mediation

Mediation is an alternative dispute resolution option where an independent professional mediator helps disputing parties settle their dispute. It is the mediator’s responsibility to facilitate discussion between the parties so that they may achieve a mutually beneficial solution. Mediation is confidential and mediators must remain impartial throughout the process. You may have your lawyer present during the mediation.

Conciliation

Conciliation is a form of dispute resolution where parties try to resolve a dispute through discussion. Conciliation is assisted by a conciliator, who is an independent party that can suggest options for resolving the dispute, provide relevant information and encourage the parties’ pursuit of an agreement. Conciliators cannot enforce decisions regarding the dispute, must remain impartial throughout the process and cannot give legal advice. As with mediation, it is a flexible and confidential process that aims for an amicable and efficient resolution. You may have your lawyer present during the conciliation process.

Arbitration

Arbitration is an alternative dispute resolution process that allows disputing parties to have their dispute decided by an independent, neutral decision maker, called an arbitrator, or in some circumstances, a panel of arbitrators.  In arbitration, the disputing parties put forward arguments and evidence that the arbitrator will assess and make a decision in relation to the dispute. The process is private and subject to the parties’ agreement, can be confidential. It is the most formal alternative to litigation. The decision made by the arbitrator, called an award, is legally binding and enforceable. You may have your lawyer present during the arbitration.

Adjudication

Adjudication is a form of arbitration that is available pursuant to Building and Construction Industry Security of Payment Act 1999 (NSW), also known as SOPA, for the prompt resolution of payment claims. Both arbitration and adjudication typically involve representation by civil litigation lawyers.

Call us to arrange a free 20 minute no obligation consultation that includes case evaluation and cost estimate.

3 lawyers discussing legal questions

 

Litigation

The civil litigation lawyers at BSM law firm Sydneyhave experience in federal, supreme, district and local courts as well as in tribunals and arbitrations. It is important to know which court or tribunal to file a proceeding in as different courts and tribunals have different jurisdictions, or the ability to make decisions and judgements. This is based on a number of factors including the proposed cause of action and monetary limits. In addition, court rules and procedures in relation to documents and complying with dates are complex and strict. It is important to engage an experienced lawyer to navigate this process as mistakes can be costly both in terms of money and time.

The standard process of a litigation hearing involves the plaintiff, who is the person commencing the legal proceedings, drafting, filing and serving a statement of claim. A Statement of claim sets out the plaintiff’s cause of action and damages, compensation or other remedies sought. The defendant is then obliged to file and serve a defence within 28 days. During this process the parties or the court may direct that the parties participate in mediation.

The court will then list the matter for a directions hearing and among other things provide a timetable for lay and expert evidence and eventually a hearing. A hearing is the presentation of each party’s position, evidence and legal submissions and will result in the court making a decision.

The highly experienced civil and commercial litigation lawyers at Brander Smith McKnight will listen carefully to your problem and meticulously draft the statement of claim. We provide you with the opportunity to review and revise the statement of claim prior to filing and serving it. We represent you at the directions hearing and attend to all of the legal requirements such as organising lay and expert evidence.

BSM civil litigation lawyers will, throughout the litigation process, seek to negotiate a rapid settlement to the matter. Apart from the alternative dispute resolution techniques previously discussed, we use tactics such as offers of compromise and interlocutory applications to gain an advantage to our clients and seek to settle the matter with minimal legal costs.

Interlocutory Application

An interlocutory application is an application filed with the court during the course of legal proceedings that may be used to gain a tactical advantage. For instance:

  1. An application for security of costs
  2. An application to strike out pleadings
  3. An application to transfer proceedings to a different court

This can occur anytime from the filing of the statement of claim prior to the commencement of the hearing. The civil litigation lawyers at Brander Smith McKnight law firm are experts at using these techniques to gain an advantage for our clients.

 

FAQs

chevronDo I Need to go to Court if I am in a Commercial Dispute?

You do not necessarily need to resolve your commercial dispute in court. A dispute can also be resolved outside of court using alternative dispute resolution methods. Such methods include mediation, negotiation, conciliation and arbitration. A civil litigation lawyer can explain these options to you and advise you on the suitability of these options. Our Sydney lawyers are well versed in the intricate mechanisms of commercial litigation and alternative dispute resolution and will provide tailored advice to achieve the best possible outcome for you.

chevronCan Evidence from the Parties Negotiating a Settlement outside of Court be used as Evidence in Litigation?

Generally no. Such evidence includes communications between the disputing parties and legal documents prepared in connection with the attempted negotiation. These legal documents are referred to as ‘without prejudice’ documents. However, there are several exceptions including circumstances where the parties consent to the evidence being adduced in court proceedings or where the evidence includes a statement indicating that it was not to be treated as confidential. The civil litigation lawyers at Brander Smith McKnight Lawyer Sydney can provide you with the full spectrum of exceptions.

chevronDo Lawyers Need to inform Clients about Alternative Dispute Resolution Options?

Yes, in NSW, a commercial litigation lawyer has an obligation to inform clients about the alternative dispute resolution options available to them. Brander Smith McKnight Sydney Lawyers are experts in alternative dispute resolution (ADR). Our lawyers work hard to settle your matter using ADR techniques as it saves our clients time and money. We continue to attempt negotiation with the other party prior to and during litigation to expediate a cost-effective outcome for our clients. We provide a free, no obligation 20-minute free assessment of your case.

chevronWhat is the Difference between Civil and Commercial Litigation

In Australia civil litigation is an umbrella term which refers to all private litigation between individuals, businesses and government entities including companies, trusts, sole traders and partnerships that does not involve criminal charges. Commercial litigation is a term frequently used in the USA to describe civil litigation involving business entities. The civil and commercial litigation lawyers at Brander Smith McKnight Sydney Lawyers have decades of experience in litigation and will fight for your legal rights.

chevronWhat is Litigation

The term litigation refers to the legal resolution of disputes in court. However, in reality many of these disputes are resolved without going to court using alternative dispute resolution and also tactics such as interlocutory applications. Brander Smith McKnight Lawyer Sydney resolve 90% of these disputes without the need for costly litigation.

BSM Lawyer Sydney has conveniently located Offices

Sydney CBD

icon

Level 57 25 Martin Place Sydney NSW 2000

Sutherland

icon

Suite 2/9 15 East Parade Sutherland NSW 2232

Parramatta

icon

Level 14, Suite 2/3 Parramatta Square Macquarie Street Parramatta NSW 2150

Wollongong

icon

Level 1, Suite 1 90 Market Street Wollongong NSW 2500

Shellharbour

icon

Unit V20, Shop 1 4 Benson Avenue Shellharbour City Centre NSW 2529

Suite 2/9 15 East Parade Sutherland NSW 2232

Level 57 25 Martin Place Sydney NSW 2000

Level 14, Suite 2/3 Parramatta Square Macquarie Street Parramatta NSW 2150

Level 1, Suite 1 90 Market Street Wollongong NSW 2500

Unit V20, Shop 1 4 Benson Avenue Shellharbour City Centre NSW 2529

 

Your Civil and Commercial Litigation Team

Mark Smith

Principal

View profile
Senior Associate BSM Law Sydney

William Onishi

Partner

View profile
Civil Litigation Associate BSM Law Sydney

Kyle Dmoch

Senior Associate

View profile
Lawyer BSM Sydney Construction Law

Curtis Newbitt-Hill

Senior Associate

View profile
Farman Suleymanli Civil Litigation Lawyer

Farman Suleymanli

Senior Associate

View profile
Commercial Lawyer BSM Law Sydney

Tom Lawler

Associate

View profile
Josh Vangi Construction & Commercial Lawyer

Joshua Vangi

Senior Lawyer

View profile
Commercial Lawyer at BSM Sydney

Emil Lunasco

Senior Lawyer

View profile

Get in touch

Please call us on 02 8539 7475 or complete the enquiry form below for a response within 24 hours Monday to Friday.