We offer you a free 20 minute no obligation consultation that includes case evaluation and cost estimate.

Please call us on 02 8539 7475 or email us for a call back.

close

Liquidated Damages in Construction

This article discusses liquidated damages in construction law in contrast to unliquidated damages. We look at how they are applied in practice and the legal principles that govern their enforceability. We also examine how courts assess and quantify losses, the importance of expert evidence, and considerations for parties when drafting or disputing particular contract clauses.

In the event that a construction contract is breached the remedy is generally an award of damages. Damages may be divided into two categories: liquidated damages and unliquidated damages.

Liquidated Damages in Construction

Liquidated damages are a predetermined amount of damages intended to compensate a party for the financial losses arising from a breach of the contractual obligations by the other party. A liquidated damages clause, also known as an agreed damages provision, specifies a fixed amount payable upon breach and applies once liability is established. These clauses are commonly included in contracts where delays or failures could result in measurable financial harm, such as in construction projects. For example, a contract may require a contractor to pay a set amount of liquidated damages per day for project delays. The intention of such a liquidated damages clause is to motivate prompt performance by the builder and reduce the likelihood of prolonged legal disputes, particularly regarding the quantum of damages.

2 construction lawyers writing notes

Some courts may scrutinise liquidated damages clauses to ensure that the clause is not punitive. A liquidated damages clause must reflect a genuine pre-estimate of loss rather than impose an excessive or unfair penalty. If a court determines that the specified amount is disproportionately higher than the actual loss suffered, the clause may be determined to be an unenforceable penalty. This occurred in the case of Dunlop Pneumatic Tyre Co Ltd v New Garage & Motor Co Ltd, 1914, UKHL.

Conversely in the event that the liquidated damages is too low the court may determine that the liquidated damages are inadequate and further damages are available, see Cappello v Hammond and Simonds Pty Ltd in our article on Construction Delays. This landmark case has implications for both builders and homeowners. Homeowners can claim damages beyond the nominal liquidated damages amount stated in the residential building contract in cases where the amount nominated for liquidated damages is insufficient.

Advantages of a Liquidated Damages Clause in Construction

There are numerous benefits of including a liquidated damages clause in contracts. Some of these advantages include:

  1. Provides the parties with certainty;
  2. Avoids the need to prove actual loss, simplifying the recovery of damages;
  3. Shortens the process of dispute resolution; and
  4. May encourage compliance with the contract and motivate desired performance.

J-Corp Pty Ltd v Mladenis [2009] WASCA 157

In this case, the Western Australia Supreme Court considered whether a contract specifying “NIL DOLLARS ($0.00) per day” for liquidated damages excluded the right of the non-breaching party to claim unliquidated damages for unreasonable delay. The court held that the inclusion of this provision did not prevent the claimant from pursuing unliquidated damages. This decision highlights how Australian courts interpret liquidated damages clauses, ensuring that parties remain accountable even if a liquidated damages amounts are set at “NIL”. This judgment is consistent with the judgment in Cappello v Hammond and Simonds Pty Ltd.

Unliquidated Damages

Unliquidated damages are awarded by a court when the amount of loss caused by a breach of contract has not been pre-agreed in a contract. These damages compensate for actual losses arising from a breach of the contract. The amount is not predetermined, therefore, the injured party must prove the extent of their loss for the damages to be assessed by the court.     

Restitutio in integrum

Ultimately, the purpose of unliquidated damages (or any contractual remedy) is to restore the injured party to the position they were in prior to the contractual breach. This reflects the Latin principle of restitutio in integrum, meaning “restoration to the original condition”. This legal concept underpins fairness in contract law and is essential to the affected party’s protection.

Quantification of Loss for Unliquidated Damages

This can be agreed by settlement between the parties and usually requires experienced building contract lawyers negotiating or using other alternative dispute resolution techniques. However, if the matter goes to court, the amount of unliquidated damages must be decided on the evidence presented during litigation. Courts must determine appropriate compensation for unliquidated damages based on all relevant evidence. The process allows both parties to submit arguments, supporting documentation, and expert reports and testimony. The court will consider several factors, including:

Causation

The claimant must demonstrate that the contractual breach directly caused the loss they suffered. If the damage was caused by an independent event or the claimant’s own actions, it is unlikely that compensation will be awarded.

Remoteness

The damage must have been reasonably foreseeable by the breaching party and not overly remote from the breach. The topics of causation and remoteness are considered in the case of Hadley Anor v Baxendale & Ors 1854 EWHAC, an English case and discussed in the article provided in this link.Breach of Contract : Direct vs Consequential Loss        

Mitigation

The non-breaching party, must take reasonable steps to reduce the impact of the other party’s breach, referred to as mitigating their losses. If they fail to mitigate their own losses, the court may reduce the damages awarded.

Proof of Loss

The non-breaching party, must prove its loss. Any assertion in court must be proved and the non-breaching party must adduce evidence to support its claim. Evidence may include invoices, financial records, expert reports, and witness testimony.

In addition to the considerations above, judges will also consider precedents to maintain consistency in awarding damages.

Terms of the Contract

Importantly the terms of the contract will also apply and will set out which damages and which types of breaches may be excluded or included in any claim for loss. Such clauses are often referred to as limitation or exclusion of liability clauses.

Expert Evidence as Proof of Loss

Expert evidence can be crucial to substantiate a claim for the quantum of loss. Expert reports and witness testimony assist courts in determining reasonable compensation for actual loss in accordance with the contract. An expert is instructed to conduct an independent assessment to help quantify damages related to matters including building defects, loss of revenue, project delays, or loss of opportunity.

Struthers v Alistair Davies (t/a Alastair Davies Building) emphasises the importance of expert evidence following a breach of a construction contract. The claimants relied on this expert testimony to establish liability and quantify damages related to defective and incomplete work. The Court found that the expert’s evidence assisted the court in establishing the extent of the losses incurred and awarding damages that were commensurate with that loss.

Key Takeaways

  1. Ensure clarity and transparency – A liquidated damages clause must reflect a reasonable estimate of potential loss.
  2. “NIL” does not mean no liability – A contract stating “NIL” for liquidated damages does not prevent a claim for unliquidated damages.
  3. Mitigate losses – If facing a contractual breach, the party not in breach must take steps to minimise damage, as courts consider mitigation in the process of awarding damages.
  4. Keep detailed records – Documentation such as financial statements, bank statements, photographs and expert reports provide evidence of the breach and the extent of the loss suffered.

The construction lawyers at BSM Sydney Construction Lawyers are industry experts, we have decades of experience in building disputes and have superb dispute resolution skills. We consistently achieve the best possible result for our clients.

How can BSM Lawyers assist you?

Brander Smith McKnight Sydney Construction Lawyers bring over 35 years of expertise in representing developers, builders, and homeowners. Our dedicated team of building and construction lawyers are able to assist with all aspects of your matter, providing tailored legal solutions for you. We offer a free 20-minute consultation to discuss your situation and explore the best legal options available.

Call us to arrange a free 20 minute no obligation consultation that includes case evaluation and cost estimate.

FAQs

chevronWhat are Liquidated Damages in Construction?

These are pre-determined damages set out in a construction contract, also known as an agreed damages provision. They specify a fixed amount once liability is established. Liquidated damages in construction provide more certainty, avoiding the need to prove actual loss. They also tend to shorten the process of dispute resolution.

chevron Can Liquidated Damages in Construction Contracts be Challenged?

Yes. Landmark cases such as Capello, show that the court has some discretion in awarding higher damages when the liquidated damage specified in the contract is inadequate. Conversely, the court can award a lower amount of damages if the liquidated damages are considered inflated. These precedents allow building contract lawyers the ability to negotiate with the other party to vary liquidated damages. The building contract lawyers at BSM Sydney Construction Lawyers are highly experienced negotiators and offer a free 20-minute consultation.

chevronWhat are Unliquidated damages in Construction Contracts?

These are based on actual loss not a previously pre-agreed amount specified in the construction contract. They take into account factors such as causation, expert evidence, mitigation of loss, proof of loss and terms included in the contract. For instance, exclusion of liability clauses. They can be agreed by settlement through dispute resolution techniques. However, if they are not settled and go to court, the amount of unliquidated damages must be decided on the evidence by the court. BSM Construction Lawyers Sydney has building contract lawyers with decades of experience who can advocate for you in both negotiations prior to court or if the matter proceeds to court.

BSM Sydney Construction Lawyers has offices conveniently located in Sydney CBD, Sutherland, Parramatta, Shellharbour and Wollongong.

Josh Vangi Construction & Commercial Lawyer

About the Author

Joshua VangiBachelor of Laws I Graduate Diploma of Legal Practice I Admitted to Supreme Court of NSW & High Court of Australia

View profile

Joshua Vangi holds a Bachelor of Laws from the University of Wollongong and a Graduate Diploma of Legal Practice from the College of Law. Joshua is admitted to the Supreme Court of NSW and the High Court of Australia. Joshua specialises in Building and Construction Law with a special interest in complex building disputes and contracts. He also works in property disputes and civil litigation. Joshua has industry expertise across a wide range of construction law including building defects, delays and extensions of time and building contracts. He has expertise in liquidated and unliquidated damages in construction law.